Murder, She Blogged: Let's Celebrate the Spinster Detective

It’s become a truism that there are not enough decent parts for older actresses. On screen, most actresses appear to have a sell-by date, and the quality roles that are out there for older women are still exceptional enough to prompt breathless media coverage. Last year, here in the UK, thousands of people signed a petition urging broadcasters to give older women more roles. In real life, older women, particularly older single women, are all too often dismissed, facing a toxic blend of sexism and ageism. 

One of the cleverer archetypes of the female detectives capitalize on this. Presenting an unthreatening facade to the world, older women detectives usually conceal razor-sharp investigative skills and intelligence. Agatha Christie’s Miss Marple is one of the classic examples of these subversive characters. Given the title of this blog series, I couldn’t resist the chance to talk about one of the earliest appereances of the Miss Marple character on film, in ‘Murder, She Said.’ The trailer for the movie is below:

“If you think I’m going to sit back and let everyone regard me as a dotty old maid you are very much mistaken,” says Jane Marple (Margaret Rutherford) at one stage, only to go undercover as a maid in a manor house to prove the point and solve the murder. As tigtog at Hoyden About Time put it, she’s: “The epitome of hidden depths: superficially a frail old lady with no special qualities, fundamentally a preternaturally observant Nemesis of those with murderous secrets.”

To a lesser extent, you could class Angela Lansbury’s Jessica Fletcher from Murder, She Wrote (surely the title must have been a nod to Miss Marple, too) in the same category, although she is not technically a ‘spinster’ as she’s widowed. TV Tropes has a more extensive list, although I quibble with some of their conclusions (I’ve only seen the TV show, not read the books, but unless they changed Precious Ramotswe’s age dramatically, I don’t think she can really be counted in under the “little old lady investigates” category!) 

What I love about these characters is that they are quite conscious of the sexism and ageism aimed their way, and they use it to their advantage: even the “benevolent sexism” which stipulates that a “cold-blooded” murderer might hesitate before killing an older, grandmotherly figure. It’s satisfying for the viewer - and also helps to undermine (some of) these prejudices.

That’s why lots of people were upset about the plan to haul out Miss Marple for another remake, starring the wonderful but far-too-young-for-the-character Jennifer Garner. When the news broke, my Facebook stream brimmed with disgruntled fans.

As my friend the filmmaker and internet geek Campbell X put it: “Agatha Christie wrote Mrs Marple specifically as an ELDERLY spinster because she was miffed that her other characters when adapted for moving image were always made younger. And this just insults her wishes.”

Sadie Stein at Jezebel summed up many people’s views:

One word: why? Why take one of the few characters in literature who represents a woman of a certain age, who doesn’t make sexuality any part of her power, and who gives credit to a generally-overlooked segment of the population, and give it a sexy, youthful, utterly generic “spin?” 

Younger women most acutely face the slut/stud double standard; older single women get hoisted with the spinster/bachelor double standard. It’s an old-fashioned word you don’t hear much these days, but the derogatory sentiment towards older women, particularly those who haven’t settled down with a man and had children, remains.

The word originates from late Middle English, when it was used to describe women who spun for a living, incidentally at a time and place when women’s options for an independent life were severely limited in Europe. It only came to describe unmarried women in the 17th century. Like those original spinsters, Miss Marple and colleagues can be seen as models that the one option of socially approved heterosexual marriage and procreation isn’t the be-all and end-all.

Previously: About the US Killing, Lund

by Jess Mccabe
View profile »

Get Bitch Media's top 9 reads of the week delivered to your inbox every Saturday morning! Sign up for the Weekly Reader:

6 Comments Have Been Posted


The Jennifer-Garner-as-Miss-Marple news *still* pisses me off so much. It's insulting and yet another example of the stunning lack of creativity and critical thinking rampant in Hollywood. And FFS, Garner isn't even a good actress! Ugh...

I felt all these issues

I felt all these issues keenly as I was writing my script, MRS. WINCHESTER, about the ultra-wealthy Victorian spiritualist who moved West to build her never-ending house in San Jose. (It's been optioned twice and was a quarter-finalist in the Austin Film Festival competition several years ago.) The two big strikes against the script are: 1) it's an expensive period piece and 2) the main character is in her late 50s, often wearing a black veil. I've had producers ask many times if she couldn't be made younger. The answer, of course, is NO. Sarah Winchester was interesting as a young woman, but unbelievably intriguing in her later years, a fascinating lady who raised powerful feminist issues just by her existence in Victorian times. I love her for that.

No 1 Ladies Detective Agency

It's been a while since I read the books, but I'm fairly positive that like in the TV series, Precious Ramotswe is only in her 30s, late 30s at the oldest.

@de Pizan Yes, that's what I

Miss Marple

I absolutely love Joan Hickson's portrayal of Miss Marple in the BBC adaptation of the books from the 1980s- I've been watching it again with my partner recently and she's now hooked as well.

oxxqtb Ghd Planchas Baratas ogl0

GvkoGYRS <a href=>Uggs Sale Nederland</a>
chfzpbhukf <a href=>Uggs Sale Nederland</a>
BPFjLlmub zfqblc <a href=>Canada Goose Bergen</a>
GlrAZBFAfmf HkkmRIFF <a href=>Uggs</a>
stsfEBIqx XvceJRQS

euhosf Canada Goose Vest xjp1

JmbiPEGQ <a href=>Moncler Jacken Outlet</a>
prhoefaleo <a href=>Adidas Jeremy Scott Pas Cher</a>
AMRiYhwim gbtkcp <a href=>Ugg Australia Schweiz</a>
QhcDARBJegk KolmROJW <a href=>Canada Goose Jacket</a>
qvkvPRSgy ZlrhKMQO

Add new comment