Is Wonder Woman Too Muscular for the Silver Screen?

She Hulk comic coverAn old issue of wonder woman with the titular lady riding a horse

This is a dark summer for geek girls. Though superhero and comic book-based films are all the rage these days, it's male crime-fighters who get all the attention: there are no films starring female superheroes on the horizon.  

Take the whip-smart spy Black Widow, for example. The Avengers member will co-star in Captain America: The Winter Soldier in 2014, but the buzz around a film in which she is the titular character all but died out in 2012. Likewise, every attempt to make a movie focused on Wonder Woman has failed to overcome the Hollywood “prevailing wisdom” that women action heroes don't sell.

Frankly, that argument is hollow.The Hunger Games, starring deadly archer Katniss Everdeen, took in $687 million at the box office. In comic book world, the women in the X-Men have become so popular that they now have their own comic. Joss Whedon, outspoken critic of the lack of women heroes in film, is adding a woman to Avengers 2 with the Scarlet Witch. Yet the total number of women on screen is shrinking.

So why are there so few female superhero films? Hollywood's extreme beauty standards mean that studios only want to make films starring a particular kind of beautiful woman, super heroines included.

For example: Would a She-Hulk movie ever get off the ground? This isn't a wild idea—She-Hulk has been a part of the Avengers (she's Dr. Bruce Banner/The Hulk's cousin) and the Fantastic Four, and both franchises have new movies coming out in 2015. She has been a member of S.H.E.I.L.D—about which Whedon is currently making a TV show. She even once had an affair with an X-Man called the Juggernaut. She-Hulk is very much a part of the mythological universe that makes up these currently popular stories.

But would major studios ever make a She-Hulk film? She's green. She's angry. And she's big. Having only been exposed to the Hulk's blood and not to actual gamma radiation, she is less monstrous than he and has more control over her powers, but she is arguably the most muscular woman in comics at 6'7” and 600 pounds. Shapely, flexible Black Widow is clearly an easier sales pitch. 

A She-Hulk movie may never be more than a pipe dream, but I don't think it's too much to ask that some of the women in genre films weigh in at something more than 120 pounds. Instead we appear to be moving backwards. Despite the popularity among both men and women of tough-girl Katie Sackoff in Battlestar Galactica, NBC's The Bionic Woman, in which she co-starred, was quickly canceled. Smallville, which was on for ten years, gave us a Lois Lane with a third-degree black belt, and that character lives on in the Smallville comic. And yet, producer Deborah Snyder has said that Amy Adams' petite Lois Lane in Man of Steel, though “a really strong female character, and very proactive” functions primarily to save Clark “emotionally.”

Justice League movie is in the works for 2015, and as of now, Wonder Woman is slated to be a part of it. But it's going to take more than vocal comic book fans to get DC Entertainment to cast a woman who could believably be an Amazon. According to the 2004 DC Comics Reference Guide, Diana Prince/Wonder Woman was 6' tall and weighed 165 pounds. However, according to the current DC Database, she's 6' and 130 pounds. At this rate, in a few years she won't be able to stand up. But she will be more likely to get her own movie.

Man of Steel does feature a female supervillian: Faora of Krypton, a version of whom appeared in Superman and Superman II. Being Kryptonian, the earth's sun gives her the same powers it gives Superman. Given that and the casting of Antje Traue, who ably defeated aliens and humans alike in Pandorum, I'm guessing Faora will be capable of wreaking quite a bit of havoc. But it's not her movie, and it's a little hard to really celebrate a character whose primary motivation is a hatred of men. Nor is it a coincidence that the most badass woman on screen this summer is also a bad guy.

It speaks volumes that Hollywood is willing to bank on superheroes who still fit into very, very narrow and petite beauty norms. Watching a grown woman fight requires us to confront our underlying suspicion that some women will never conform.

The stunning and talented women in this summer's blockbusters are not the problem. The problem is a culture that can only stand to see women heroes who weigh no more than the average 16-year-old girl. The truth is that women of all sizes can be heroes. They already exist as such in comic books for now. Let's get some up on the silver screen.

by Holly Derr
View profile »

Get Bitch Media's top 9 reads of the week delivered to your inbox every Saturday morning! Sign up for the Weekly Reader:

10 Comments Have Been Posted

Holly writes the best posts.

Holly writes the best posts. I really enjoy your nerd analyses. Keep them coming! :)


Please don't bring up the

Please don't bring up the She-Hulk/Juggernaut thing. Many comic fans have drunk themselves to death trying to forget it.

i remember halloween

a few years back...HGC had a spinning spiral on her crotch, to hypnotize villains...BB (me) had of course a whip, Sister Fister, had, well, a giant Fist of Fury, HH was just a sexy Egyptian Harlot with sultry eyes...and the Villainess was that damn Vestal Virgin.

It's high time we see female superheroes carry their own films

'nuff said.

Agreed! Would love for my

Agreed! Would love for my sons to see female superheroes!

Thanks Holly! I think I

Thanks Holly! I think I would make a great superhero, so let's get writing.

I can't agree with this article

I completely agree that everyone is entitled to their own opinion and that writer did propose her argument well but certain aspects of this article bothers me. When reading this article (as a female nerd) I see more rant than valid argument. Wonder woman movies have been delayed due to poor writing! The script has been tossed out multiple times! Dc has even stated that the scripts were not worthy of the character. The tv show was canceled because of the ridiculous outfit changes. They had her in 6 different costumes due to fan uproar over ...DRUM ROLL PLEASE! The original skimpy outfit proposed sent fans into a nerd frenzy. NOT JUST female fans, but male fans spoke the loudest.
The black widow movie/ Wonder Woman movies were not scrapped because women don't sell as comic book movie heroes! First of all the black widow movie was a combination of her AND HAWKEYE! The reason it flat lined was because these characters don't have a big enough following to make a market gamble on. Would you really put 50 million dollars on a gamble? And I already explained what the deal was with the Wonder Woman movie. 2nd of all bringing Wonder woman's weight into play on the anthology is not a valid reason as to why a movie for her wouldn't be made. Lucy Lawless was originally asked to play her(which she does vocally in the new frontier) also Catherine zeta jones was asked to play her. If we could lets take a look at the last female to play her (although the show was scrapped) she was voluptuous! Neither one of these women's physically body type is a size 130!!!!!
Third of all she hulk CAN NOT HAVE HER OWN MOVIE! I feel enough enough she hulk comics have not been read to even suggest this character have her own movie. This character is a SUPPORT CHARACTER! Not to mention the continuous bombing of the Hulk franchise itself! She Hulk is not intended to solo! While she does have her own comic book title, the books are nothing to focus on

Add new comment